Everyday Cheapskate: Are Expensive Appliances Worth It? Not Always -- Here's When They Are

Mary Hunt on Sep 1, 2025

You're standing in the appliance aisle at your favorite home store, staring down two dishwashers. One is modestly priced at $499. The other is more than double that -- $1,299 -- and comes with all the bells, whistles, LED lights and an app that alerts your phone when the rinse cycle finishes.

So you wonder: Is the expensive one really worth it -- for me, the buyer, not the store owner?

Short answer? Sometimes.

Longer answer? Let's talk.

WHEN MORE MONEY MIGHT MAKE SENSE

1. Durability That Delivers

Higher-end brands like Speed Queen, Miele and Bosch are built to last. Instead of plastic parts that wear out or crack after a couple of years, these machines tend to use stainless steel and commercial-grade components. If you're running laundry for a family of five every few days, or your refrigerator sees more door action than a busy diner, a durable model may pay off over time.

A $400 washer might hum along for four years before giving out. A $900 one could last you 12. Do the math, and that pricier washer ends up being cheaper per year.

2. Energy and Water Efficiency

That price bump might include technology that reduces your energy use, water consumption or both. Energy Star-certified appliances often cost more upfront but can lower your monthly utility bills. That adds up, especially in areas where energy rates are anything but friendly.

And let's not forget water. Some modern dishwashers use less than half the water older models needed to get the job done. That can be a big win, both financially and environmentally.

3. Performance That Works for You

If you love to bake or cook, the right oven can be a game-changer. Pricier models often provide more consistent heating, fewer hot spots and smarter controls. The same goes for washers and dryers -- fancy cycles can actually matter if you're caring for delicate fabrics or allergy-prone family members.

In short: If the features solve real problems in your everyday life, they may be worth the extra dollars.

4. Better Warranties and Service

Sometimes a higher price includes a better warranty or more responsive customer service. If you've ever waited three weeks for a repair tech to show up (only to say they need to order a part), you know how valuable this can be.

WHEN IT"S NOT WORTH THE SPLURGE

1. Too Many Bells, Too Little Use

Not everyone needs a refrigerator that can livestream your groceries or double as a DJ. If you're not going to use the tech, why pay for it? Those fancy touchscreens may be fun, but they're also just one more thing that can break.

2. Style Over Substance

It's easy to fall for sleek lines and brushed finishes, but if the appliance isn't reliable or efficient, you may be trading long-term performance for short-term pretty. That's fine if aesthetics are your top priority -- but not so great if you're hoping it'll last a decade.

3. You're Just Not That Into It

If you're more takeout than meal prep, or you only run the dryer twice a month, you may not need the heavy-duty features of a top-tier model. Don't spend big on something that won't get regular use.

HOW TO BUY SMART

Know your needs. If you cook a lot, invest in a good stove. If laundry is your nemesis, get a washer built for battle.

Research reliability. Some brands look great but have high failure rates. Check out Consumer Reports or trusted review sites.

Consider lifetime cost. Factor in energy usage, warranty coverage and repair costs -- not just the sticker price.

Mid-range can be the sweet spot. Often, you'll find excellent quality and performance without breaking the bank.

FINAL WORD FROM THE BUYER'S SIDE

I've owned the budget-friendly models and the high-end showpieces. My advice? Don't assume a high price means high value. Focus on what fits your lifestyle, budget and expectations.

Because when it comes to appliances, you want them to work hard -- not your wallet.

========

Mary invites you to visit her at EverydayCheapskate.com, where this column is archived complete with links and resources for all recommended products and services. Mary invites questions and comments at https://www.everydaycheapskate.com/contact/, "Ask Mary." This column will answer questions of general interest, but letters cannot be answered individually. Mary Hunt is the founder of EverydayCheapskate.com, a frugal living blog, and the author of the book "Debt-Proof Living."